Research Integrity
Responsible scholarly evaluation considers publication ethics, editorial accountability and the mechanisms used to address concerns about the integrity of the scholarly record.
SIIFI · EVALUATION & METRICS
Explore the principles, evidence standards and methodological foundations of SIIFI journal evaluation. Understand how assessment criteria and responsible metric interpretation fit together.
Our Evaluation Principles
Responsible journal evaluation extends beyond numerical indicators. It requires attention to research integrity, transparent publishing practices, verifiable evidence and independent judgment, while recognizing the limitations of journal-level metrics.
Responsible scholarly evaluation considers publication ethics, editorial accountability and the mechanisms used to address concerns about the integrity of the scholarly record.
Clear policies, accessible methodological information and identifiable publication records help scholars understand the basis and limitations of journal assessment.
Evaluation findings should be grounded in relevant, traceable evidence and interpreted through clearly defined assessment rules.
Credible assessment requires independent judgment and careful interpretation of journal-level indicators, with expert evaluation and methodological limitations kept in view.
Journal-level metrics inform scholarly assessment; they do not replace expert judgment or establish the quality of individual research contributions.
THE EVALUATION LIFECYCLE
Explore how journal applications, identity information, scholarly evidence and applicable methodology inform the SIIFI evaluation process—from initial submission and assessment to authorised publication and record verification.
A journal application is received and recorded.
The stated journal identity and preliminary eligibility are examined.
Relevant scholarly publishing records are examined.
Evidence is considered under the applicable authorised methodology.
Assessment findings undergo authorised consistency review.
An authorised result is made publicly identifiable.
Published information remains traceable over time.
These seven phases explain the evaluation lifecycle; they are not seven separate system status codes. Publication depends on an authorised decision. Certificates are verified only when issued. The motion is illustrative, not live application tracking.
EVALUATION CRITERIA & SCORING FRAMEWORK
Explore the questions, evidence types and methodological safeguards relevant to scholarly journal assessment. Approved numerical rules must be identified separately from research-informed criteria proposals.
Methodology disclosure · Please read before exploring
SIIFI's supplied database records an approved SAJEF 2026-v1 methodology entry. However, the available documentation does not specify a public criterion-by-criterion scoring rubric, maximum marks, weightages or aggregation formula. The ten domains below are research-informed proposals, not published official SIIFI scoring criteria. No journal-specific marks are displayed.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 01 / 10 · PROPOSED
Can the journal and its publisher be reliably identified?
Journal title, identifiers, website and publisher details are internally consistent.
Official journal pages; ISSN Portal records when accessible; publisher disclosures.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
Ownership, contact channels and possible impersonation concerns can be examined.
Publisher identity statements; public contact and title-history records.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 02 / 10 · PROPOSED
Are editorial responsibilities and independence documented?
Editor-in-Chief, Board roles and relevant expertise are disclosed.
Public board listings; institutional affiliation sources where available.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
Editorial independence and conflicts-of-interest procedures are explained.
Editorial governance and conflict-of-interest policies.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 03 / 10 · PROPOSED
Is the stated review model transparent and credible?
Peer-review type, decision responsibility and reviewer expectations are documented.
Peer-review policy; review timelines and published process information.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
Special issues and reviewer conflicts are addressed appropriately.
Special-issue policy; reviewer ethics and conflict procedures.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 04 / 10 · PROPOSED
Are research-ethics responsibilities appropriately addressed?
Authorship, plagiarism, competing interests and research ethics are covered.
Public publication-ethics and authorship policies.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
Corrections, retractions and complaints have documented routes.
Correction/retraction procedure and published notices where available.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 05 / 10 · PROPOSED
Can the journal’s publication history be traced?
Volumes, issues or continuous-publication dates are identifiable.
Article archives, publication dates and issue listings.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
The stated frequency or continuous-publication model is represented consistently.
Publication schedule, archive chronology and policy statements.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 06 / 10 · PROPOSED
Does published work match the journal’s scholarly purpose?
Aims, scope and article categories are clearly stated.
Aims-and-scope page and author guidelines.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
A sample of published material can be examined for scope consistency.
Article titles, abstracts, article types and reporting information.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 07 / 10 · PROPOSED
Can citation-related claims be traced and interpreted responsibly?
Citation sources, coverage and time periods can be identified where used.
Documented bibliometric datasets and source descriptions where authorized.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
Potential citation anomalies and field differences are considered.
Citation distribution, exclusions and methodological limitations where available.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 08 / 10 · PROPOSED
Are scholarly records identifiable and findable?
Articles carry consistent identifiers and bibliographic metadata.
Article landing pages; metadata records; identifiers where used.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
Identifiers and article links resolve appropriately where applicable.
DOI resolution or other persistent links; public archive records.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 09 / 10 · PROPOSED
Are access terms and continuity measures understandable?
Copyright, licensing and access terms are disclosed.
Rights notices, access policy and license statements.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
Long-term access and archival arrangements are explained.
Archiving and preservation policy statements.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
RESEARCH-INFORMED DOMAIN 10 / 10 · PROPOSED
Are editorial and publishing responsibilities clear?
Fees, ownership and service conditions are made understandable.
APC/charges pages, publisher information and disclosures.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
Contact, complaints and appeal mechanisms are identifiable.
Contact pages, complaints policy and correction procedures.
Assessment method, marks and mandatory status: Not specified in a published criterion-level SIIFI rubric.
SCORING TRANSPARENCY
For an official scoring table, each criterion must have a documented definition, maximum marks, weighting rule, evidence standard, treatment of missing or non-applicable information, and an applicable methodology version. Those numerical details are not available for public verification in the supplied materials; no numeric allocations are inferred.
A journal quality-assessment score is not automatically equivalent to a citation-based impact metric. Published numerical results require the applicable approved method, evidence, evaluation year and appropriate interpretation.
EVIDENCE VERIFICATION & RESEARCH INTEGRITY
Credible journal evaluation requires careful examination of scholarly records, publishing practices and supporting evidence. From editorial governance and peer review to journal identifiers, publication ethics and citation patterns, verification findings must be documented and interpreted in context.
Conceptual verification model · Not a live automated scan or journal-specific finding.
EIGHT EVIDENCE REVIEW AREAS
Select an evidence category to examine its purpose, potential sources, verification approach and limitations.
EVIDENCE REVIEW AREA 01 / 08 · EXPLANATORY
Editorial identities and responsibilities.
EVIDENCE REVIEW AREA 02 / 08 · EXPLANATORY
Declared review practices.
EVIDENCE REVIEW AREA 03 / 08 · EXPLANATORY
Serial identity and title consistency.
EVIDENCE REVIEW AREA 04 / 08 · EXPLANATORY
Persistent identifiers and records.
EVIDENCE REVIEW AREA 05 / 08 · EXPLANATORY
Publisher responsibility and disclosures.
EVIDENCE REVIEW AREA 06 / 08 · EXPLANATORY
Archives and publication chronology.
EVIDENCE REVIEW AREA 07 / 08 · EXPLANATORY
Policies, corrections and accountability.
EVIDENCE REVIEW AREA 08 / 08 · EXPLANATORY
Citation context and unusual patterns.
Responsible interpretation. Missing information, conflicting records or unusual citation patterns require contextual review and do not automatically establish misconduct. These evidence areas describe research-informed verification considerations; they do not assert that SIIFI operates automated registry checks or has adopted each procedure as a mandatory evaluation rule.
BIBLIOMETRIC METHODOLOGY & IMPACT METRICS
Journal-level citation metrics depend on defined data sources, publication windows, eligible document types and explicit calculation rules. Explore the principles behind reproducible bibliometric analysis and use an educational demonstration to understand the arithmetic without confusing it with an official SIIFI metric.
THE SCIENTIFIC COMPONENTS
Each component requires an explicit, authorized rule—not a visual assumption.
Identify the provider, coverage, retrieval date, matching rules and limits of the observed citation data.
Distinguish the citation period, eligible publication years, data snapshot and metric release date.
Define which document types enter the publication count, including date, Early Access and duplication rules.
Specify treatment of duplicates, self-citations, retractions, missing metadata and exceptional records.
NUMERICAL TRANSPARENCY
Both populations must be constructed from traceable records using the applicable rules. Their relationship alone does not establish an official SIIFI formula.
Early Access, eligible document types, duplicate records and retractions require explicitly documented treatment.
Conceptual components only · Not an official SIIFI formula
SCIENTIFIC METRIC INTELLIGENCE
Explore a conceptual view of how a published indicator should be interpreted. This visualization does not demonstrate or reproduce SIIFI's internal calculation method.
RESPONSIBLE METRIC INTERPRETATION
An authorized quality assessment may consider journal identity, editorial governance, peer review, research integrity and transparency under its own approved criteria.
A citation-based indicator depends on data coverage, time windows, eligible works, exclusions and a separately documented mathematical method.
Journal Quality Assessment Is Not Citation Impact. A quality score cannot be converted into an impact metric by arbitrary scaling. Citation metrics also do not establish the quality of an individual article or researcher; field differences and dataset coverage matter.
SIIFI is an independent scholarly evaluation initiative. Any SIIFI metric must be interpreted under its own authorized methodology and must not be represented as a Clarivate Journal Citation Reports Journal Impact Factor.
SCIENTIFIC ANALYTICS & EVALUATION INTERPRETATION
Scholarly evaluation data becomes meaningful when its sources, context and limitations are understood. Explore how citation patterns, evidence coverage, assessment components and research relationships can be visualized and interpreted through responsible analytical methods.
SCHOLARLY ANALYTICS & INTERPRETATION STUDIO
Choose an analytical perspective to examine its definitions, required data and scientific limitations.
VIEW 01 / CITATION TREND
Citation trends describe changes in observed citation activity across defined periods. Interpretation depends on consistent datasets, counting rules, publication coverage and citation windows.
Observed counts or defined indicators across comparable observation periods, if reliable data is available.
Changes may reflect citation behaviour, publication output or dataset coverage—not necessarily changing research quality.
Missing observations must not be plotted as zero or connected as a continuous verified trend.
A coverage percentage requires a defined set of applicable requirements, review states and an approved denominator.
VIEW 02 / EVIDENCE COVERAGE
Coverage can describe which defined documentary requirements are available, reviewed or incomplete. It must not be mistaken for an integrity rating or overall quality score.
Completeness and review status of specifically defined evidence requirements when records support the calculation.
Coverage may help identify documentation gaps and pending verification, but it is not a certificate of research integrity.
Missing, not applicable and unreviewed items require explicit rules before any proportion can be calculated.
VIEW 03 / SCORING BREAKDOWN
A valid scoring breakdown distinguishes criterion definitions, applicable maximum marks, awarded marks and approved weightages under a specific methodology version.
How an authorized quality assessment is distributed across eligible criteria when the corresponding records are public.
Maximum, awarded and weighted values describe different quantities and must be labelled separately.
An overall metric cannot be reverse-engineered into criterion-level marks or converted automatically to citation impact.
VIEW 04 / RESEARCH NETWORK
Network diagrams can represent defined scholarly relationships, such as one work citing another. Their meaning depends on node identity, edge semantics, direction and source coverage.
How a directed citation edge could connect a citing scholarly work to a cited work.
Network position and connectivity need contextual methods; an edge means only the relationship actually defined.
A citation link does not establish collaboration, academic merit, endorsement or misconduct.
Methodological transparency: These four views currently explain analytical concepts; this development package does not contain authorized journal-specific datasets for public charting. Journal-level indicators support context-specific assessment but do not determine the quality of individual articles or researchers.
METHODOLOGY GOVERNANCE & RECORD INTEGRITY
Scholarly evaluation records require clear methodological references, year-specific interpretation and traceable decisions. Explore how methodology versions, annual assessments, corrections and certificate verification contribute to accountable evaluation records.
01 / GOVERNANCE CONTINUITY
A published evaluation should reference the applicable approved methodology and its version. A framework title alone does not establish a numerical formula.
This five-stage sequence explains governance concepts; it does not represent completed SIIFI approvals, a particular journal evaluation or live verification status.
A methodology version identifies the rules that apply to an evaluation. A later revision does not automatically replace the method used for a previously published year.
No specific SIIFI version dates or approval events are asserted in this explanatory section.
A published journal metric remains associated with its actual evaluation year and applicable methodology. A new or pending assessment does not inherit an earlier year's result.
The year represented by the assessment.
The governing method applicable to that record.
The date an associated certificate was issued, if any.
The documented certificate expiry date, if applicable.
04 / RECORD CONTINUITY
Each action has a distinct meaning. A request or concern does not, by itself, change an authorized public result.
A correction addresses an inaccuracy in a specific record; a methodology amendment changes the governing rules. Material amendments should be traceable to an authorized decision and the affected record or version. Do not silently rewrite historical evaluations.
Any request for clarification, correction or reconsideration must be assessed under the applicable authorized SIIFI procedure, where one has been established. Submission alone does not change a published evaluation. No appeal deadline, fee, entitlement or guaranteed outcome is specified here.
A formally authorized withdrawal of the relevant validity or status.
The recorded validity period has ended; this is not a misconduct finding.
A later authorized document replaces an earlier one for a defined purpose.
Reinstatement, if permitted, requires an applicable approved process and authorized decision. A printed certificate alone does not establish current validity.
Use SIIFI's existing certificate verification service to check the registry's recorded issuance, correction and revocation status. An historical PDF is not proof of current validity.
siifi.org/verifyIndependent scholarly evaluation. Published SIIFI records should be interpreted in their actual year, methodology and status context. This explanatory section does not publish fictional approvals, annual results, appeal outcomes or certificate decisions.
ACADEMIC KNOWLEDGE & SCHOLARLY ACCESS
Clear answers about SIIFI's ECP assessment process, evaluation standards, scholarly evidence, journal metrics and public record verification.
A quality assessment examines defined editorial, publishing and evidence-related standards. A citation-based metric concerns citation activity under specified data and calculation rules. These indicators represent different assessment dimensions and must not be converted into one another without an approved methodology.
SIIFI uses its own ECP assessment process to examine relevant journal information, scholarly documentation and applicable evaluation standards. The assessment considers available evidence under the authorized procedure. Submission of an application does not guarantee a particular evaluation result or published metric.
Relevant evidence may include editorial information, peer-review policies, publication ethics, publishing history, article records and supporting documentation. The actual requirements depend on SIIFI's applicable ECP standards. Evidence must be interpreted in context, and missing information alone does not establish misconduct.
No. An ISSN identifies a serial publication, while a DOI identifies registered digital content. These identifiers do not independently establish editorial quality or effective peer review. Journal quality requires consideration of applicable publishing standards, documented practices and supporting evidence.
A reproducible citation metric requires defined data sources, observation periods, eligible publications and calculation rules. The applicable SIIFI method must establish these elements. A particular citation window or mathematical formula must not be assumed when it has not been formally documented and authorized.
These matters require documented citation-analysis rules and appropriate evidence review. Duplicate relationships, self-citations, withdrawn content and incomplete records may require different treatment. Unusual citation activity alone does not establish improper conduct, and official exclusions must follow the applicable approved methodology.
Citation counts can vary because sources differ in coverage, reference matching, record updates and document eligibility. The selected observation period can also affect the result. Counts should therefore be interpreted alongside their data definitions and known limitations.
Meaningful comparisons require compatible metric definitions, evaluation rules, data sources and observation periods. Differences in publication characteristics and methodology versions may limit direct comparison. A higher or lower number does not, by itself, establish overall journal quality.
Citation trends describe observed citation activity. Evidence coverage concerns documentation and review status. Scoring breakdowns explain applicable assessment components, while research networks represent defined scholarly relationships. Each analysis has a specific purpose and limitations; none independently establishes overall quality.
"Under Evaluation" means that the relevant assessment has not yet produced an authorized published outcome for that period. A previously published metric may remain associated with its original evaluation year. It must not be presented as a new result for a later pending assessment.
Evaluation Year identifies the year of an assessment. Certificate Issue Date identifies when the certificate was issued. Valid Until indicates its recorded expiry date, where applicable. These details are distinct, and current certificate status should be checked against the official SIIFI record.
A methodology revision changes applicable assessment rules, while a record correction addresses an identified inaccuracy. Material changes should be appropriately authorized and traceable. Historical evaluations should retain their original year and applicable methodology unless an authorized correction establishes otherwise.
Publishers may contact SIIFI at evaluation@siifi.org with the relevant evaluation reference, a clear explanation and supporting information. Requests are considered under applicable authorized procedures. Submitting a request does not automatically change a result or guarantee a particular outcome.
Expired indicates the end of a recorded validity period. Revoked refers to an authorized withdrawal of status, while Superseded indicates replacement by a later record. Not Found means a matching accessible record was not located. The authoritative verification result determines the actual recorded status.
Evaluation results should be read alongside their methodology, evaluation year, evidence basis and documented limitations. A numerical result cannot describe every aspect of a journal's publishing practices. Responsible interpretation considers both the assessment outcome and the scope of the applied standards.
SIIFI conducts assessments through its own ECP process and applicable evaluation standards. Relevant scholarly information, supporting documents and available evidence are examined under the authorized procedure. Evaluation outcomes are determined according to the applicable rules and authorized assessment decisions.
Understand the Process. Interpret the Evidence. Verify the Record.
For evaluation-related enquiries: evaluation@siifi.org